Skip to content
Chaos Lab

Challenge 57 · intermediate · OTP sign-in

A million codes is not enough

Users sign in with a 6-digit code sent by SMS, valid for 5 minutes. The gateway limits code checks to 10 a second per IP. Real users sign in 100 times a second. At 10 seconds a botnet of 5,000 machines starts guessing codes on 1,000 accounts: 40,000 guesses a second, 8 per machine. At one in a million a guess, that is an account every 25 seconds. This is a fictional, self-contained simulation.

From 15 to 75 seconds, let at most 100 attacker guesses a second be checked, while at least 99% of real sign-ins succeed.

ready00:00 / 01:15Success · 10 s–p99 · 10 s–Taken over0Codes used twice0

Goal · measured 00:15–01:15

0 changes · par 2
  • Attacker guesses checked a second ≤ 100/snot measured yet
  • Real sign-ins succeeding ≥ 99.0%not measured yet

This is a simulation. Its numbers come from a model of a typical system, not from measuring real servers. The same link and seed always give the same run. How the Chaos Lab works.